Is God’s mercy greater than Justice?
While preparing to teach Sunday School, I felt I needed to talk about Alma 42 instead of the assigned reading in Alma 43-52.
I wasn’t sure why I felt this way, but when I turned to ChatGPT for a better understanding of God’s mercy, I immediately knew why we needed this lesson.
For those who don’t know, ChatGPT is an AI system that can help you with pretty much anything. From help to planning a Sunday School lesson to budgeting a trip, ChatGPT can provide clarity and insight to complex questions such as, “Is God’s mercy greater than justice?”
Here’s what I prompted ChatGPT, along with the answer I was provided: In Alma 42, there is a lot of talk about justice and mercy. Can you expand upon it? How is Christ able to be both just and merciful?
Alma 42 offers a profound discussion on the interplay between justice and mercy, particularly in the context of God’s plan for humanity. Here’s a deeper exploration of these concepts and how Christ is able to embody both justice and mercy:
Understanding Justice
• Definition: Justice is the principle that every action has consequences, and everyone receives what they deserve based on their actions. It demands that laws be upheld and that penalties are administered fairly.
• In the Context of Sin: In Alma 42, Alma explains to his son Corianton that because all people sin, justice requires that they be punished according to the law. Sin separates us from God, and justice would demand that this separation be eternal because nothing unclean can dwell in the presence of God (Alma 42:13-14).
Understanding Mercy
• Definition: Mercy is the compassionate treatment of a person, where leniency or forgiveness is granted instead of strict justice. Mercy allows for the possibility of redemption and the alleviation of suffering.
• In the Context of Sin: Mercy provides a way for sinners to be forgiven and reconciled with God. However, mercy cannot override justice without undermining the law and God’s justice.
The Dilemma Between Justice and Mercy
• The Problem: Alma articulates a fundamental problem: how can God be both just and merciful? If God is perfectly just, He cannot simply overlook sin. On the other hand, if He is perfectly merciful, He cannot punish those who repent, or He would violate the very nature of mercy.
• God’s Dilemma: Without a resolution, humanity would be eternally separated from God due to sin, as justice would demand. Mercy, without a way to satisfy justice, would negate the need for law and order, leading to chaos.
Christ as the Mediator
• The Role of Jesus Christ: Jesus Christ is the key to resolving this dilemma. He satisfies the demands of justice by taking upon Himself the punishment for sin. Through His Atonement, Christ pays the price for humanity’s sins, thereby fulfilling the demands of justice (Alma 42:15).
• Justice Satisfied: Because Christ has suffered for the sins of the world, justice is satisfied. The law is upheld because the penalty for sin is paid in full, but by Christ rather than the sinner.
• Mercy Enabled: With justice satisfied, mercy can be extended to all who repent. Because Christ has already paid the price, God can forgive sinners without violating the law of justice. This enables God to be merciful while remaining just (Alma 42:22-23).
How Christ is Both Just and Merciful
• Perfect Balance: Christ embodies both justice and mercy because of His unique role as the Savior. He is just because He ensures that the demands of the law are fully met—no sin goes unpunished. At the same time, He is merciful because He offers to bear that punishment Himself, thereby providing a way for sinners to be forgiven and return to God.
• Mediator Role: Christ’s role as mediator is crucial. A mediator is someone who intervenes to reconcile two parties in conflict. In this case, Christ mediates between God’s justice and humanity’s need for mercy, bringing about reconciliation between God and humankind.
Practical Implications for Believers
• Repentance: Alma emphasizes the importance of repentance. Christ’s Atonement opens the door for mercy, but only for those who repent. Repentance is the process by which individuals acknowledge their sins, turn away from them, and seek forgiveness through Christ.
• Grace: Mercy is extended to those who have faith in Christ and accept His grace. Grace is the enabling power that allows individuals to overcome sin and be sanctified, ultimately becoming worthy to return to God’s presence.
• Hope: The message of Alma 42 offers hope to all people. It reassures that, despite their sins, there is a way to be forgiven and cleansed through Christ. This hope is grounded in the understanding that justice and mercy are not at odds but are harmonized in Christ’s Atonement.
Conclusion
In Alma 42, the balance between justice and mercy is one of the most profound teachings of the gospel. Christ is both just and merciful because He satisfies the demands of justice through His Atonement, enabling mercy to be extended to all who repent. This perfect balance allows for the laws of God to be upheld while also providing a path for sinners to be forgiven and return to God’s presence. The chapter highlights the depth of God’s love and the brilliance of His plan, where justice and mercy coexist in perfect harmony through Christ.
—
Isn’t this incredible? These talking points lead to a lengthy discussion about mercy, grace and how God can be both just and merciful.
At lunch time, I sat down with my children and had a similar discussion, however, this time I used an analogy to explain what mercy and justice mean for us.
Imagine you are speeding, and a police officer pulls you over.
You were going 35 over the speed limit, and now the police officer has one of three options.
Depending on where you were speeding, you may go to jail for reckless endangerment, you could get a ticket, or you may leave with just a warning.
The law requires that a punishment (this is justice) is put in place, but in that moment, the officer can extend mercy if he or she decides to do so.
If you are let off with just a warning, does that mean God’s mercy can override justice? No, it cannot and here’s why.
In this scenario, the police officer is able to extend mercy because Jesus Christ already paid for your ticket, and all the tickets you will receive in the future, however, that doesn’t mean every time you’re pulled over, you will walk away with a warning. Sometimes community service or paying the ticket is a lesson God wants you to learn, however, at any moment, God is able to extend mercy because His Son (who volunteered) Jesus Christ paid on your behalf.
Mercy is something God chooses to give because He can.
Justice is required due to the nature of His laws, however, because His Son Jesus Christ volunteered to pay the price for our actions, God can choose to be merciful.
Like God, we to have a choice to be merciful to others and ourselves.
What matters most to God is what we choose to become because He has extended mercy to us time and time again.
Are we willing to extend mercy to those who have done us wrong?
Although easier said than done, God’s mercy is a blessing, and is available to all of us as we choose to repent and follow Him.